Home
NEW TODAY
SCRIPT DEADLINES
TODAY'S POLL
WATCH FREE FILMS
MOVIE VIDEOS
ARTIST PROFILES
Movies by Year
Movies by Director
Movies by Actor
Movies by Actress
Movies by Alphabet
MOVIE CHARACTERS
MOVIE FRANCHISES
2012 MOVIES
2012 MOVIE LIST
2011 MOVIES
Book of Possibilities
The Writer's Way
Film making TIPS
Sex Articles
Best of SEXY
KISSING scenes
ROMANTIC scenes
SMOKING scenes
TEEN Movies
ACTION movies
HORROR movies
FAMILY movies
Box Office Results
TOP 100 STAR WARS
STEVEN SPIELBERG
THE AVENGERS
DARK KNIGHT RISES

Subscribe To This Site
XML RSS
Add to Google
Add to My Yahoo!
Add to My MSN
Subscribe with Bloglines
 

STRAW DOGS, 2011
Movie Reviews!

Search 1,000 of MOVIES
SCREENPLAY CONTESTSUBMIT your SCREENPLAY
Voted #1 screenplay contest in the world!
wildcardWATCH - Best of FILM INDUSTRY VIDEOS!TOP 100TOP 100 LISTS WEBSITE
Best of photos, movies, sex and everything else!
2011 MOVIES2011 MOVIES
See all of 2011 films!
 MOVIES YEAR BY YEAR

See and watch films 1900 to present!
CLICK and WATCH MOVIES ONLINE!
WATCH today's TOP SHORT FILMS
EXPLORE and WATCH the TOP PAGES on THE NET!!
wildcardWATCH the best of WILDCARD PICTURES! wildcardWATCH the best of SHORT FILMS on the NET!

  MOVIE POSTER STRAW DOGS, 2011
Movie Reviews

Director: Rod Lurie

Stars: James Marsden, Kate Bosworth, Alexander Skarsgård, Dominic Purcell, James Woods, Willa Holland, Laz Alonso, Walton Goggins

Review by Joshua Starnes

WATCH THE MOVIE TRAILER

SYNOPSIS:

L.A. screenwriter David Sumner (Marsden) relocates with his wife Amy (Bosworth) to her hometown in the deep South. There, while tensions build between them, a brewing conflict with locals becomes a threat to them both.

REVIEW:

The good thing about a remake is a modern version of an older film, whether we like it or not, is easier to introduce to a new audience than trying to get them to sit through the original. For an important film, or a film dealing with important themes, that is not a small gain.

The bad thing about them is that they're frequently pointless, offering little more than a better technical rendition of what has come before with nothing new to add to it. Rod Lurie's remake of "Straw Dogs" is somewhere in between those two poles.

In the new version of Sam Peckinpah's classic, sleepy Wales has been replaced with sleepy Blackwater, Mississippi where residents do three things: hunt, drink, and watch high school football. Into this God fearing, gun totting atmosphere comes successful screenwriter David (James Marsden), you're typical liberal Hollywood type who does care for guns or God and is far more interested in chess and Beethoven than football and Lynerd Skynerd. He and his actress wife (Kate Bosworth) have returned to her old homestead for peace and quiet. Unfortunately a lot of Southern resentment and an old boyfriend (Alexander Skarsgard) are what's waiting and soon everyone is re-evaluating what exactly it is they know about themselves.

The original "Straw Dogs" was a meditation on the glorification of violence in cinema by one of its masters, using pure savagery to focus audiences on the reality of their desire to see a bad guy get what's coming to them. In the wake of "Hostel" and the "Saw" franchise where loving depictions of torture has become entertainment, a look into the psychic rewards of violence on those who perpetrate it – no matter how justified it may be – is particularly trenchant.

Understanding this, and how well the original covered this territory, writer-director Rod Lurie ("The Contender") has hewn pretty close to the first version with little deviation in the plot. Even the final climactic siege of the Sumner household is played out beat for beat nearly the same as the original.

Which allows all of those original themes to be brought to the surface in the complex way Peckinpah did. Though outwardly peaceful, several of the residents of Blackwater gradually become more and more contemptful of David, pushing him and Amy for a reaction. Rather than the typical Hollywood reaction, Amy herself begins to have contempt for David and his refusal to make a stand as well, pushing him to change his most deeply held beliefs. It doesn't help matters any that David and Amy are newlyweds and are only just beginning to discover they don't really know each other that well.

Things come to a head when some of the boys take David out hunting, leaving Amy at the house alone. While Peckinpah approached this sort of thing with his typical vivid, scathing violence, Lurie makes one of his few major departures choosing to focus on the psychological realities of what is happening and characters making momentary decisions they immediately regret.

And he has a great deal of support from his cast. As unhelpful as it is to follow Peckinpah, Marsden has the unenviable job of stepping into a young Dustin Hoffman's shoes. Though not as good a fit for the idea, Marsden makes David his own and believably switches back and forth between being a jerk and a victim. It's a thin line to walk and he does it well. It helps that he has a fine counterpart in Skarsgard, and most of the films best scenes involve the quiet tension building between the two. Skarsgard's Charlie gets most of the new interpretation as well, turning him into a slightly more complicated character who is counter intuitively more of a villain.

But the reality is there's just not enough different here to really make it worth the time of anyone familiar with the original "Straw Dogs." It does bring up things that are still worth talking about but for those who've never seen the first version the films themes are likely to be as misinterpreted as the originals were. It's not a waste by any stretch, the performances are too good and it's important ground that needs to be covered, but it can't overcome the specter of the original.

TOP 100 SEXTOP 100 SEX SCENES of all-time
WATCH the revised 2011 list!
 TOP 100 NAKED MOVIE SCENES
WATCH the all! Best in cinema history!
TOP 100 TV SEX SCENESTOP 100 TV SEX SCENES
WATCH the best in television history!
wildcardWATCH - Best of ET Radio PODCASTS!
CLICK and WATCH MOVIES ONLINE!
CLICK HERE read more life lessons COLUMNS!

MOVIES YEAR BY YEAR
CLICK the LINKS and EXPLORE
2005200620072008200920102011
19971998199920002001200220032004
19891990199119921993199419951996
19811982198319841985198619871988
19731974197519761977197819791980
19651966196719681969197019711972
19571958195919601961196219631964
19491950195119521953195419551956
19411942194319441945194619471948
19341935193619371938193819391940
19261927192819291930193119321933
1918191919201921 1922192319241925
19101911191219131914191519161917


STRAW DOGS, 2011